Friday, December 5, 2014

A Good Day As a Teacher

A lot of the time, it is tough being a teacher. I generally lean toward seeing the negatives more easily than the positives and I worry a lot, so the bothersome or cruel things that students say and do often stand out to me more and have a bigger impact than the kind or awesome things that I see every once in a while. But today, a student said something that made all those negative things (and all the stress of my first year last year) worth it.

I brought my Thesis (well, technically my "Research Question," but trust me, they are basically the same) to school with me because I was going to drive to my college and hand it in to my advisor right after school. Also I wanted to show that 31-page, 29-source bad boy to my students so they'd understand why I am not very sympathetic when they complain about writing 3-page essays and having to use MLA format.

When I showed one class, the kids started asking about my Master's degree, since I told them I'd be graduating next week. They wanted to know if I'd make more money with that degree. I said yes, a little more. They also wanted to know if I wanted to teach college and if that was why I was getting the higher degree. I said that I had thought about that some and might in the future someday, but that I really just wanted to get the Master's for myself, and that I preferred teaching high school to my time as a graduate assistant because I got to make relationships with the students.

To this, one of the girls said, "Well, you at least have to stay here until I graduate. That's just two more years. You can't leave before then."

I told them I could probably last at least that long. ;)

This comment really made my day. I can remember last year when one of my favorite teachers from my own time in high school was retiring. Several students tried to persuade him to stay by saying, "Just stay a couple more years until I graduate! I want to have you as a teacher again." All last year, perhaps because it was my first year and I was extra self-conscious, and perhaps because I was not as good then at dealing with unwanted behaviors of students, I felt that probably more of my students would rather have had me leave than stay. This year, things are much better, but it is still rare for students to say aloud things like this that clearly mean: "I like you. I want to be taught by you." Even though I'd like to imagine myself as tough, caring more about effectively imparting knowledge to students than whether or not they like me, I realize that students respect teachers more if they like them, and are much more willing to learn from them. Not every student will like me, and I know that types of students come in waves and I will probably have tough years in the future. However, it is nice to know that at least some of my students appreciate me as a person and a teacher.

Oh, that same student, upon hearing that the topic of my Thesis was dystopian fiction, wanted to read it. She loves books like Divergent and I mentioned that I wrote about books that had come before that one - classic dystopias like 1984. She insisted she was sincere in wanting a copy, so I printed one for her and she seemed really excited to read it. I asked her not to judge me if it was boring to her, but secretly I hope she'll like it and maybe even decide to try reading one of the novels that forged the way for modern dystopias like those by Veronica Roth.

Friday, July 11, 2014

The Story of Matt's Lost Ring

I'm going to tell you a crazy story about Matt "misplacing," as he calls it, his wedding ring, and then finding it again. Let me preface this with the story of why our rings are extra special to us, and you will then understand my feelings during this ordeal.

Matt and I made one another's wedding rings. We are not jewellers, and therefore we've had a couple of ... difficulties with this decision, but I'm still glad we did it. The rings were perfect for our wedding day, and I'm dealing with any imperfections a little better now than I did when they first occurred (I'll get to this later).

Matt made my ring from palladium, which is VERY sturdy, but very hard to work with. The solder he used was also difficult to work with. He started on the ring more than a year before we got married and finally gave me the finished ring two days before our wedding. The ring is a band with a rose-like flower that holds the diamond. It is modelled after a ring of my grandmother's. The way he chose to create the ring called for a lot of soldering of small parts together, and it was tedious and did not always go as planned. Until he started putting all the parts together, I wore the band as an engagement ring. But when it was done, it was gorgeous and very special. Worth the wait (like Matt ;) ).

I am even less skilled at making metal things than Matt, so I made his ring from iron in his grandpa's shop. He helped me cut a thin strip which we then hammered on the anvil into a circle, ground smooth, and soldered the thin opening between the two ends. It's nothing fancy, but it was something I could make.

Here are the rings on our wedding day:



As I said, they were perfect for the wedding, but mine was just not as sturdy as it needed to be for everyday wear. Really, the only actual thing that went wrong on it's own was that the diamond was loose within the prongs and after about a month, it fell out. Luckily I found it in the house right away. We left the diamond out for a while, but when Matt tried to put it back in and hammer the prongs down (with tools made for doing this), the prongs came loose from the solder joint. In trying to solder the prongs back in later, the rest of the solder melted (you have to get it EXTREMELY hot to solder it, and it is hard to pinpoint one small area on something already so small), and the rose became unattached from the band. For a while, I've been wearing just the band and we've decided to wait before trying to put it all back together because it is difficult with the materials Matt has, and also stressful. I think he wants to try something new in the future, and we've discussed getting a ring made to look very similar from a professional near our next anniversary. I'd be a bit sad not to wear the ring HE made for me, but I'd still wear the band he gave me, and I know in the future he'd like to try making a new ring for me from easier-to-work-with materials.

Matt's ring is sturdy - the only problem is that it can rust, not something you normally want in an everyday ring. So, he takes it off a lot when he is doing things where he'll get his hands wet. It is also a tiny bit loose (because he is a bit claustrophobic when it comes to wearing things), so he also takes it off to sleep and when working on things with his hands. We have a little dragon figurine whose tail is made for holding rings, and that is where the ring is supposed to go, but Matt sometimes just leaves it on the counter near where he is working, or occasionally puts it on the sink lip.

I promise I am getting to the story soon.

I have sometimes wondered if we should have just bought rings - it was a very stressful process hoping Matt could make mine in time, and then when he tried to fix it later ... but looking back, I'm glad we did what we wanted and made rings for one another. They may not have turned out perfect, but we can still remember the hard work we both put into making the rings for our wedding, and I have slowly decided that we could have rings made for everyday wear and still keep the old ones somewhere special, and they won't lose their importance for us. I think the story of our rings reminds me that even though we may not be able to make everything perfect for each other in life, we are still willing to put in effort to do what would make the other person feel most loved (because Matt's tradition of making me things makes me feel very loved), and likewise, we are both willing to look past the imperfections and find the value and beauty in each other.


OKAY HERE IS THE STORY in case you were getting bored and started scrolling down to see how long this would be.


I'm not even sure how long ago it was now - maybe a month, maybe two? - when I noticed I hadn't seen Matt's ring in a while. He doesn't really wear it at home, but I see it sitting around wherever he has temporarily stored it.

I asked him about it and he said he wasn't sure where it was, but thought he had just set it somewhere and he was sure it was in the house or at his parent's house (where we'd visited recently and done some things outside, so I guess he thought he'd taken it off for some reason there).

I was busy with a summer class at the time, but in my spare time I tried to clean up bits of the house, looking for it. I checked all his pants pockets and the washer and dryer. Not there. We looked everywhere with increasing desperation, at least on my part, over the course of a month. Matt checked at the house where he stays when he is away for work. Not there. I checked the bathroom and counters at his parent's house when we went there, even though I was sure if they'd seen it they would have said something. Not there.

I was starting to give up hope. I thought maybe Matt had set it on the kitchen counter and Llyr had knocked it to the floor and under something, but when I searched everything it could be under, it wasn't there. Then I thought maybe he'd left it on the sink counter in the bathroom and Llyr had knocked it in the small trash can next to the sink. After having spent a few weeks with it missing already, I knew that trash was long gone. I was sure the ring was gone forever.

I wasn't even sure how to think about this. I didn't want it to be true, and I just felt empty and distraught, but unable to even cry, when I thought about the ring I made for Matt being gone. I mean, it wasn't anything fancy, but it was special. Just like my ring was - even now, it is still special and I would feel devastated if I lost it.

I could go on about the worried thoughts that I tried to ignore for the most part because I really didn't know where else it could be .... but I'll get to the end of the story, which, thankfully, is happy.

We went to Matt's parent's house again a couple of days ago. Matt got out of the driver's side and bent down to get something from the back seat.

He said, "Elizabeth, you're going to want to see this."

I first thought it was maybe some weird or neat thing - like a Killdeer nest (Matt loves those birds), but he picked up something off the ground and started to come over to me on the passenger side.

I am bad about not trusting Matt when he brings over things in his hand. I'm always afraid it will be some bug or yucky creature. I asked it if was alive.

He said no, and then it clicked.

"Is it your ring?"

"Yes!"

I was SO relieved and happy.

The gist is that Matt must have had the ring in his pocket when getting into the car one time, and it fell out. For who knows how long, it had lain in the gravel part of his parent's driveway, unmoved. When he picked it up, it was wrapped around a small rock. Maybe someone drove over it or stepped on it and pressed the two together? Matt took the ring off the rock before taking a picture, but later really regretted not saving the rock as part of the crazy story. I'm just glad the ring is not lost forever.

The ring is a bit rusty now, and Matt has placed it on the dragon tail for safe keeping. I'm sure we can easily clean it up soon. We've now talked more about getting professionally made rings on a future anniversary so that Matt's can fit better and won't rust, and mine can be complete as it is supposed to be. But, I know we will still wear and keep the ones we made and treasure them forever.

We both just can't believe it was right there the entire time, and that Matt saw it there among the rocks, not even purposefully looking for it. He says a lifetime of looking at the ground to pick up coins and neat rocks prepared him to find it.

Thursday, July 3, 2014

Review: Every Day by David Levithan

Mid-June, I read David Levithan's Every Day. I've been getting through several YA novels this summer that are on the state reading lists for the upcoming school year, and this was one of them. Sadly, I ended up not liking the book very much. I say sadly because I was really interested and excited about the idea of the book . . . but the execution did not appeal to me. You can find many other reviews on the book that give you a synopsis, but I'll give a short one here:

Narrator/main character "A" wakes up every day in a different body. A resides in each body for one day only, and usually just tries to fit into the person's regular routine and not shake things up. The reader follows A through a couple of months at age sixteen (A only wakes up in the bodies of people the same age as A). One day, A falls in love with Rhiannon, the girlfriend of Justin, a boy who A inhabits. A wants to try to keep seeing Rhiannon, but as you can imagine, A's situation makes this difficult. (Luckily A swaps between people usually within a few hours of one another.)

The idea was really neat I thought, and I wanted to see how the author explained how A would deal with the difficulties this kind of life would bring. I will not be too wary of spoiling things, so watch out.

Positives: The interesting idea. Each chapter is a different day, a different person, and there are a couple that are really touching in how A deals with the person's situation (for example, deciding to "interfere" and tell a suicidal girl's dad how she feels, when A usually tries not to interfere too often). And, the few "bonus" chapters at the end detailing some days before the novel starts were pretty good as a short story on their own.

Negatives: Almost everything else. Number 1, which most of the other reviews I read after finishing the book hit on as well, was that the narrator is too "preachy." Really, it sounded like I was just reading the author's thoughts instead of a distinct voice for A. The reason for this probably stems from the fact that author David Levithan is gay, and in this novel he makes a LOT of statements through A about tolerance and acceptance. Now, I'm not against those ideas being in YA novels. However, to me it felt like the author was telling me how to feel through his narrator, instead of letting me decide for myself or make a judgement based on the actions of the characters. Plus, there were some times when I just didn't agree with the main character's ideas on those subjects. That's my own personal opinion, I know, but it colored my reading, so I'll be honest about it here.

A is especially repetitive about convincing Rhiannon that A sees him/herself as neither a a boy nor a girl. I can understand the reasoning behind that, given that A switches between the two all the time. It is harder for Rhiannon to wrap her mind around this - which I can also understand, because living 16 years in one body would make it hard to understand. I imagine A as a boy, probably because A first appears in the body of Justin (Rhiannon's boyfriend), so even though the author probably would not like it, I'm going to call A "he" from now on for consistency and ease of writing. I noticed that a lot of reviewers also automatically called A "he" and did not mention that A sees him/herself as neither, so I felt like I at least wanted to mention this fact. (I do wonder if the love interest had been a boy rather than a girl whether I/others would have viewed A more as a girl.)

So, one thing that bothered me stems from the above point. When A meets up with Rhiannon in a girl's body (often going to great lengths and breaking that vow of not meddling with the body's life), it is harder for Rhiannon to show A affection. A seems to try to make Rhiannon feel guilty about this. That's bothersome. Rhiannon is clearly a heterosexual female, and has lived so for 16 years. Even if you agree (like A seems to think), that we should just "love who we love" regardless of gender or anything, that does not negate that fact that most people are attracted to one over the other, and it's not Rhiannon's "fault" that she feels awkward being with A as a girl.

Also, I don't like that A is so selfish. He tries to make it like he's not, but he is. This is realistic, but hard to read in the first person and still "like" the narrator. He falls in love with Rhiannon while in Justin's body and he just "knows" that Justin is a jerk and Rhiannon deserves better. A acts like he is far beyond his years, which I guess is believable considering the way his life has been lived, but he sounds pompous sometimes. Besides just seeing Rhiannon more often, then finally spilling his secret, he tries to persuade her to break up with Justin, and not even very subtly (maybe that's better, though). He pretends it is for her own good, and maybe it is because Justin kind of is a jerk, but clearly A is also being selfish. Then he wants Rhiannon and him to be able to have a relationship, and ignores how difficult this will be for her - she is clearly unsure about it and finally makes it clear that it just can't work, him trying to see her all the time and dragging all these bodies all over the place. She can see that this is selfish, and he only seems to see his desire for her. Ok, a couple of times he debates and maybe realizes that this is not fair to his hosts, and I will grant that it does not seem fair for A that his life has to be lived the way it does and he can't really have a stable family and friends - but another part of me was like, well, this is the hand he has been dealt and he is going to have to live with it, as cruel as that may be.

MAJOR END-OF-BOOK SPOILERS AHEAD

Towards the end, A wakes up in the body of a boy he deems a nice guy, and he asks Rhiannon to meet him and pretend it is their first date. He has, by this time, figured out how to sort of implant what memories he wants the body's real inhabitant to keep the next day. So, the boy A is in will remember meeting Rhiannon and going on a stellar date with her. That night, he basically tells Rhiannon to stay with this guy and start a new relationship with him. Yeah, he basically picks out a guy for her since he can't be with her. Weird, controlling, and silly.

Last, the final thing that made me most angry with this book. Here is a specific passage that may illustrate the preachy-ness and how the book is really not-so-tolerant-as-it-purports-to-be in some cases.

Day 6023: "Even before I open my eyes, I like Vic. Biologically female, gendered male. Living within the definition of his own truth, just like me. He knows who he wants to be. Most people our age don't have to do that. They stay within the realm of the easy. If you want to live within the definition of your own truth, you have to choose to go through the initially painful and ultimately comforting process of finding it."

Problems with this passage:

A) I have a more objective view of "truth." While I realize that some things we call "truths" can be subjective (say, I might say "Math is hard" and that may be "true" for me but not for someone else) I think "Truth" needs to be objective or how can we have it? So I'm not sure what A means, "the definition of your own truth." I guess he means that you could be born female, like Vic,  but feel that in "truth," you are male.

B) The bigger issue: I feel the author is basically saying that anyone who is cisgender (I think I am using that correctly: someone whose "mental" sex aligns with their physical sex, as opposed to transgender) is limited, scared, or wrong. As if because I was born female, identify as female, and am attracted to men, I am taking the "easy" path. I'm sorry, but this does not mesh with everything I hear about people being "born" the way they are, their identity and desires not necessarily up to them to "choose." Levithan's narrator says "find," I guess, but what does that mean? I have to go out and try everything out to figure out what I already knew about myself? And if I don't choose to do this or don't "have to do that" as he says, am I somehow inferior than those who did have to do so? I can understand that the types of people he is referring to go through a lot of angst and perhaps persecution for "living in their own truth" ... but I am offended by this passage that makes it seem like I am taking the easy (suggesting inferior) path.

Levithan may not have meant consciously to make his writing sound this way, but to me it does. I felt continually bombarded by A's thoughts and opinions without room to make my own conclusions. I think drawing conclusions rather than being told what to think or how to feel is important in a YA novel. Yes, in school we (I'm a teacher) guide students to understand certain readings of books, but hopefully we do so in a way that helps them make their own assumptions and conclusions. Plus, I hope most of us let them keep their own opinions about the story, even if to us personally that opinion is skewed or missing something. We present the ways of looking at the story, but we don't force them to change their beliefs or morals or opinions about situations. Levithan's book made me feel like I was being forced to listen to the narrator's beliefs on everything and like if I had a differing opinion, I was being stupid, like Rhiannon when she could not show affection to A as a girl as easily.

I was sad that a book with such an interesting and promising premise turned out difficult to read. I tried imagining that A, being a teenager, is just spouting his own ideas, like teenagers do, and it was up to me to look at him as a person with flaws (selfishness, rash action) as well as good things, and make my own judgements on what he said ... but at the same time I felt that despite the fact that A is flawed as a character, the author wanted me to completely agree with all his opinions. It's hard to explain this. I guess I feel like an impressionable young reader might just take the word of this narrator as gospel without really thinking about what is being said or who is saying it because it is said in a more eloquent tone of the "teenager that every teenager wants to be," smart, funny, witty, etc. Overall, I like the idea and one or two interesting or poignant chapters, but overall Levithan's writing and A's voice made it not enjoyable for me.

Tuesday, June 24, 2014

Bridal Shower Projects

Over the weekend, I attended a bridal shower and bachelorette party for a friend who is getting married in July. Since I am a bridesmaid, I helped with some of the decorations and planning. My favorite thing to make was the lighted marquee sign. I got a pinterest email on Monday that showed one and I thought, "I can do that!" I can't believe I was able to find materials and order lights in time, but I got it done pretty much all between Thursday and Friday, and I think it turned out great!




I made this apron because the shower was sort of "kitchen" themed.
Here's the start of the marquee. Unfortunately, her soon-to-be-new-last-name has a lot of popular letters, and I could only get a G in the big letters. Plus there were no Es at all ... I bought two number 3s and flipped them around. Actually, I ended up liking the eclectic look.
I marked enough spots for 35 holes, since I bought a strand of christmas lights from LED warehouse with 35 lights. It was only $12 with shipping, it came in like, 3 days, and the LEDs should not get hot, so it should be fairly safe.

I glued and nailed the letters overlapping, but in the end this was not strong enough and I had to cut a backing, But, that helped hide the cord.

I drilled the holes with a 3/8 bit once I got the light strand and figured out how big the holes would need to be for the lights to slide in easily.
Oops, small accident. As I was cutting, the E broke a little. These letter are not exactly wood, they are like, chipboard sort of, but anyway, more fragile than cut wooden letters might be. I might cut my own in the future if I were doing a larger marquee.

After a lot of work, the holes are cut and the letters are glued to the backing and painted. The only bad thing was that since some letters are overlapped, those lights have to push through the backing and a space before getting through the letter, and some were not lined up exactly perfect, even though I tried to mark them well. So, in the future I might not overlap letters like that.
It works!
Fancy!
I also put these flowers in the colander using "wet foam" and aluminum foil to cover the holes.
All the decorations! I made bottles that say "Eat, Drink, and Be Married." Also, there is a frame with a sign that says "All you knead is love." I got the idea for that on pinterest. I'll include a printable version for you!
 All in all, it was a fun weekend and I was excited to make these things for my friend. I am definitely going to try the lighted sign again on a project for me! 

Here is the printable:




Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Summer Projects So Far

Well, the busy school year slipped into a busy summer. With a summer class and a lot of weekend trips in the last few weeks, I did not get back to blogging about my summer projects as soon as I wanted to. The other reason I have not made time to blog about the projects is that, well, I've been out working on them so much! But, I wanted to at least share some pictures of what I've worked on so far this summer, in case they inspire you to do some summer projects of your own!

(As I went through pictures, there were also some from our trips that I wanted to share. I love Matt's new camera. It can make anything look lovely, including me, and especially our handsome kitty!)

This is a greenhouse made of windows and with only cat-safe plants (catnip, cat grass, basil, mint, etc). It has plants growing now, but Llyr still prefers yard grass to the cat grass, unfortunately.
I put together the blocks of this quilt earlier this year and I just got it back from being quilted. I'm not exactly sure who did the blocks, because they are hand stitched. I think my grandmother or her mother. My mom recognized some of the fabric but was not sure who made them. I plan to give it to my grandmother and ask her then.

These glass doors came from Matt's great-grandparents' house. They were hung in the kitchen in front of an in-wall shelf. We rescued them last year before the land and house were sold. I wanted to make a standing bookshelf/cabinet out of them and it is now finished! That's right, Matt and I are the masters of making more furniture fit in our overfull house. The picture wall had to change up a bit, but we got it to work. The blue decorative things on top of the bookshelf also came from the house - they'd been in the corners of the porch. It is really cool to give new life to these neat old things from Matt's family.
Learned last year that polyurethane is not meant for outdoor furniture. Oops. It all peeled off our pew. Finally got around to fixing it. Matt sanded off most of the peeling poly. I jig-sawed off the yucky leg and the other to match (which means it is kind of short now, but I could build something for it to sit on later). Then, I used Thompson Water Seal and a couple of layers of Besty Ross House Blue outdoor paint after that had dried. Hopefully now it is protected against the elements! I don't mind a bit of wear, I mean, we saved it from a brush pile .... but I want it to stay in the condition it is, not get any more worn down.
Here is the pew and the chairs I am painting to match. Again, another failed attempt with the polyurethane that had to be fixed. Oh well, bright blue is nice, too. 


Big Events !

Llyr has made a friend! Actually, he has made three new friends, but this guy brought them over to our house to meet him after Llyr had cozied up to him (and after we put out some food for this friend ... he was starving!). We just call this guy Friend for now. Llyr loves to go out and visit him. Llyr has gotten a little more bitey and rowdy with him in the last couple of days. I hope it is play fighting and they will stay buddies, because Llyr needs some kitty friends to play with. This picture captures Llyr's awe during the early stages of making friends. He's like, "It's another cat, like me, and he's not running away from me or being mean! Joy!"
We went to Harry Potter Trivia Night with friends and got 15th out of 25 teams. Some of the questions were tough! I was proud of us for our first year. It was a blast. I loved dressing up and making snacks.
We took a trip to see a Cardinals game and to visit the Arch with my family. Matt had never been in the Arch before (I had).

 Just Some Final Pretty Pictures I Wanted to Share

 
 

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Review: Witch and Wizard by James Patterson

Just finished Witch & Wizard by James Patterson. The bad news: it was not exactly what I was expecting. The good news: it made me feel more confident about the writing abilities of my 10th graders this past year. I'll explain what I mean by that later on.

First of all, my expectations. I had seen this book around and--this is pretty superficial, but don't judge--the cover looked cool and the title was catchy. I was intrigued. After reading the back cover, which introduces Whit and Wisty Allgood, the teenage protagonists, I was even more interested, A) because it was Young Adult fantasy literature, which I enjoy, and B) (again, perhaps superficial) because their names were cool. I guessed quickly that Wisty was short for Wisteria, and I thought Whit was short for Whitman. I thought, that would be a neat baby name for an English major (I would probably not name my own kid that, not being a huge Whitman fan, but it's interesting nonetheless). Whit is a cute nickname. I expected literary allusions galore. There were a few. Whit actually stands for Whitford.

I think the problem was that I was expecting a Young Adult novel geared towards adults, or that would interest adults. For example, I think the Harry Potter series is a  Young Adult series that could be appreciated by adults. Also, books by Tamora Pierce. I should maybe have taken the hint that the readership age was intended to be a bit younger when one of my 8th graders was reading it, but some of them read a variety of books which are intended for slightly older readers.

While the idea behind the novel was interesting (the New Order bans books, music, and art of the previous era, and most importantly, anyone associated with magic), the set up of the book left something to be desired. I expected more detail and background about the New Order and about the main characters, but the reader is thrown right into the action. Sometimes that is an interesting choice for a novel, but in this case everything just went very fast, the villains were kind of flat, and the chapters were very short and sort of episodic. It was very plot based. Whit and Wisty narrate the story to the reader, which is ok, but their voices are a bit too ... stereotypical "teenager," is the best way I can describe it. Like, a little contrived, maybe?

I did not hate it, but I was expecting a little more grown up fantasy, I guess, especially from James Patterson, who regularly writes books for adults. I'll admit, I've only read one, and it was a long time ago, so I don't know his writing style well, but I know he writes a lot of detective stories. Not to say there is anything wrong with him writing this, but I see that it is not what I was looking for when I picked it up off the shelf.

Regarding how it made me feel about my 10th graders: I will say that reading this book made me feel better about the novel my 10th graders wrote for National Novel Writing Month and that I am working on final-editing so we can self publish it. Their main characters were all teens, too. The characters' way of speaking could have been more realistic in some cases (I thought, how many of you speak like this? Why are you making your characters speak like this?). Their novel was very plot-centric, with not a lot of character development, but there was some sporadic background information and some attempts at making the characters change or grow. The chapters were a bit longer than Patterson's, his being around 2-3 pages each, very choppy. My students' chapters were very episodic, too, but that's because I gave each person a different chapter and we tried to plan out the chapters by events that would happen in them so that it was easier for them to outline and write them in one month. The story itself was a little inconsistent in some places--I tried to amend some of that here and there without changing too much of what they wrote--but for forty 16-year-olds who are not all keen on writing, I was pretty proud of them. Patterson's novel was fast-paced, like theirs, with one thing popping up after another. I feel not so critical of them after reading his novel.

I am afraid that sounds cruel to Patterson, but really I think it's just that I expected something meant for older teens and adults. Geared toward younger teens, I'd say the story would definitely keep them reading. Perhaps the same can be said of my 10th graders' novel--geared toward their age group, it's definitely an action-packed story that, although it may not be the peak of literature, is enjoyable nonetheless.

P.S. Just after posting this, I found what looks like a graphic novel version of the book - I think that might work well. The artwork would be a fun addition and maybe the style of the story would work better in graphic novel form. 

Saturday, May 31, 2014

Review: The Circle by Dave Eggers



I've decided to kick off my return to blogging with a book review, but let me warn you that posting a review of this particular book on a blog strikes me as somewhat ironic .... Anyway, I'll get to that.

It has been a busy past few months, but I'd like to return to sharing some of my upcoming summer projects, and I'd also like to start reviewing some of the books I read this summer - so there is a a clearer purpose, perhaps, to my frenzied reading. I plan to tackle at least 10 books this summer, more if possible.


I recently finished The Circle by Dave Eggers. I'd heard a bit about this book--set in a dystopia where an internet company, rather than the government, is the tyrannical force--and I love dystopian fiction, so I was excited to try it. I also love me some Margaret Atwood, and she calls the book "Fascinating . . . [A] novel of ideas . . . about the social construction and deconstruction of privacy, and about the increasing corporate ownership of privacy, and about the effects such ownership may have on the nature of Western democracy" according to the back cover of the novel and this article. Looking back, I guess the praise here is mostly stating what the book is about ... but I figured if Atwood said it was fascinating, it must be good.

In the end, I think what she said about a "novel of ideas" is a good way to put it. I think the idea of the novel really intrigued me, and was an interesting idea to explore, but perhaps the execution of the novel was not as good as it could have been.

Unfortunately, about 60 pages into the novel, I decided to read some other reviews, and I'm afraid they colored my further reading negatively. Some other reviewers did not seem to like the book, while others said the idea was good but perhaps not well played out.

Mia Lipman says: "It's not subtle, but neither were "Harrison Bergeron" and 1984, and in its best moments The Circle is equally terrifying. Let's just hope it's not prescient." 

She's right. It is not subtle. One review called it propaganda-like ... Eggers makes it very clear that the "utopia" the Circle is striving for is anything but. However, going into the novel knowing it was dystopian, that wasn't really a surprise.

Ellen Ullman writes for the New York Times Book Review: "The Circle adds little of substance to the debate. Eggers reframes the discussion as a fable, a tale meant to be instructive. His instructors include a Gang of 40, a Transparent Man, a shadowy figure who may be a hero or a villain, a Wise Man with a secret chamber and a smiling legion of true-believing company employees. The novel has the flavor of a comic book: light, entertaining, undemanding.

Readers who enter the Circle’s potential Inferno do not have the benefit of Virgil, Dante’s guide through hell and purgatory, but they do have Mae, a naïve girl with the sensibility of a compulsive iPhone FaceTime chatterer. (Oddly, Mae does not lead us through the ranks of programmers — let alone offer a glimpse of a woman programmer — a strange omission in a book purporting to be about technology.)" 

Ullman is right that Mae is pretty willing to take in every new thing the Circle suggests ... she squashes down the ever-widening rip of anxiety that she--justifiably--feels as things get worse and worse. With her for the protagonist, it was a bit hard to keep reading enjoyably, and perhaps Mae is more naive and compulsive and willing than a real person would be ... but I think not.

In fact, the more I read, the more scared I became that there are many Maes out there. At the risk of sounding conspiratorial, I do think that teens are being raised in a world that tells them to share everything, and tells them that this is good. If they already willingly share so much on media sites, and in person, I don't think it would be hard to get them to share more, like the Circle encourages employees to do in the book. On the subject of compulsion, one thing that made my cringe so much while reading is that I, sometimes, can be as compulsive as Mae when it comes to checking things off a list.

The innumerable amount of tasks Mae is asked to do seems impossible time-wise, but I could see how she would feel compelled to do everything asked of her (and she is basically told she has to). To be more specific, Mae starts out answering customer queries. She sends a quick review after each one, and if she does not receive a 100 rating, she sends a follow up to try to see what she could have done better. Usually the customer will then recant and give a 100. This is her regular job at first. But later, she is asked to also keep up with messages from bosses and workers around "campus," be a part of many groups and activities, send out "zings" (which are sort of like tweets or instagram posts), and answer survey questions through headphone throughout the day. She is expected to reply to thousands of messages from coworkers a week, answer a "quota" of around 500 survey questions a day or more (which Mae pushes towards 1000), put in extra hours for activities with co-workers, recommend products at a rate that 250 or more people per week choose to purchase the same items, and several other daily tasks. It is a bit impossible to believe she can make time for it all. Ignoring messages or prompts just gets her more messages and anxious requests for answers. 

Everything the employees do is rated, and although at one point someone says Mae is not judged by this rating ... clearly, clearly she is meant to be judged by her rank. She spends hours (meticulously detailed by the author) in raising her rank by commenting, posting, and the like. It is as if to feel valuable she has to share or tell or be a part of everything. There are pages of descriptions of the amounts of things ... I see that Eggers is trying to show how the Circle tries to make everything quantifiable, and it is maddening.

The leaders of the Circle want everything to be known, leaving no room for crime because everyone is watched or can be watched. Here, it becomes very much like Big Brother, and though the transition seems fast, it is meant to be taken in steps, one slightly more invasive thing after the next. And most people willingly eat it up. The ones who protest are bewildering to Mae.

I think overall, the book did have interesting (and scary) ideas ... and ones I could believe in the possibility of. That's one factor I believe is necessary in a successful dystopian novel: it has to seem, on some level, able to happen. I think some readers might say the transition happens too fast and people wouldn't really go along with it, making the book seem unreal. However, I read two Facebook posts while reading The Circle that made me fear that people are already being pulled into this life of sharing everything with everyone. One of the posts stated that the writer felt scorned by family and wanted them to state, on Facebook, why they were mad at him (even though he acted like he already knew). He said he wanted them to reply to his post, or be cowards and send him a private message. As if airing dirty laundry is the brave and right thing to do, instead of having a meaningful, private conversation about those things. But in the book, that's how everything is viewed. "Secrets are lies; privacy is theft." Mae can't have any personal moments or private hobbies; she is expected to share them all and others are hurt if she chooses not to.

The book was a bit long and had a TON of specific examples that just got worse and worse, as in, worse to imagine. It made me very confused about my use of technology, such as this blog. I think I am still pretty selective and careful about not OVER-sharing, but I do have to check myself sometimes when I think "Oh, I could say ______," and then I realize there's really no reason (or in fact it is a bad idea) to share said information.

Towards the end of the novel, I knew where things were going and just wanted the anxiety and anticipation to end, but I'm glad to have tried it out. It was worth reading for the ideas and it definitely made me think.